The Rest Is Politics589. The Trump-Xi-Putin Summit and Can the UK Ever Trust America Again?
17 Nov 2026 · 74 minThe United States is entering an era where its global influence is no longer unbounded, necessitating a fundamental shift towards genuine power-sharing and co-dependency with allies, rather than expecting unilateral deference.
Summary
This conversation dissects the evolving landscape of global power dynamics, particularly focusing on the US-China relationship and the future of Western alliances under a potentially resurgent Trump administration. Jake Sullivan, a former US National Security Advisor, offers an insider's perspective on high-stakes diplomacy with China and Russia, contrasting traditional US foreign policy with Trump's personalized approach. The discussion highlights the erosion of trust among allies and the intellectual challenge of envisioning a US foreign policy that genuinely prioritizes collective interest over American exceptionalism.
Interesting ideas
Trump's 'Big Boys' Diplomacy Reshapes Global Order. Donald Trump's preference for personalized leader-to-leader diplomacy, exemplified by a potential three-way summit with Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin, signals a rejection of democratic solidarity and allied coalitions. This approach devalues allies, portraying them as liabilities rather than assets, and suggests a world where 'big boys sit down and decide things,' leaving smaller nations to follow. This fundamentally challenges the post-WWII US-led order and could embolden adversaries like Putin who seek to frame such meetings as a new Yalta conference.
China's Ambivalent Approach to Global Governance. China's leadership often advocates for universal global governance through bodies like the UN, appealing to the Global South for a more equitable forum. However, it simultaneously benefits from the 'G2' concept (US-China duopoly), which implicitly tells American allies their input is less significant. The inclusion of Russia in a 'G3' complicates China's narrative, as it struggles to reconcile its multi-alignment rhetoric with participating in a de facto 'great powers' club, indicating an internal tension in its strategic communication.
The Peril of US Weaponized Interdependence. The US's historical use of its financial and technological dominance (e.g., secondary sanctions, control over tech stacks, and critical software like F-35 systems) has created a deep dependency among allies. The guest argues that this 'weaponized interdependence,' particularly under a Trump presidency, has broken trust to a degree that requires tangible concessions, not just promises. Allies seek guarantees against arbitrary cut-offs of essential technologies, questioning whether the US can genuinely cede control to rebuild mutual trust.
Xi Jinping's Calculus on Taiwan and the PLA. Xi Jinping's timeline for Taiwan likely hinges on the 2028 elections. A KMT victory might validate his 'pressure and coercion' strategy, while a ruling party win could prompt military action if he believes political change is impossible. However, Xi also weighs Trump's unpredictability and the People's Liberation Army's (PLA) readiness, particularly after recent purges. These factors suggest Xi may not be in an immediate rush, but 2028 remains a period of heightened risk for Taiwan.
Rebuilding Trust: Beyond Sentimentality to Structural Change. Alliances rely on both sentimentality and logic, but the former has eroded significantly. Rebuilding trust in the post-Trump era demands structural changes, such as guaranteed access for allies to advanced AI models and shared control over tech ecosystems, rather than mere promises. This 'lashing to the mast' with allies, by removing some US agency and empowering partners, is seen as essential for collective resilience against competitors and could be 'saleable' to an American public that still values alliances.
Questions worth thinking about
If the US were to genuinely cede control over key technologies to its allies, what practical mechanisms would be needed to ensure this is irreversible and not subject to future political shifts?
How can European 'middle powers' effectively leverage their collective economic and technological strengths to create genuine counter-leverage against US unilateralism, beyond mere rhetorical complaints?
Given the current US domestic political climate, how feasible is it for any future American president to advocate for a 'humbler, practical' foreign policy that involves actual compromises and power-sharing, rather than simply a more benevolent form of US leadership?
Written by AI from the episode's full transcript. It can get things wrong: if something here looks off, tell us at hello@podpings.com.